Fortran --> timing factorials

[danbaron]

I made a program to calculate factorials using Fortran.

Fortran doesn't have a big integer type, so, I had to do everything myself.

First the program calculates and prints 1000!, as a check. I'm pretty sure it is correct.

Then it calculates and times factorials up to 200,000.

The calculations are done using base 10^8. Then, the answers are converted back to base 10 (base 10^1). The conversion is included in each time.

The speeds are good compared to my earlier attempts, but bad compared to, for instance, Python.

http://www.thinbasic.com/community/showthread.php?11537-Python-3-gt-Timing-factorials&p=85675#post85675

Whether I can do better, remains to be seen.

Only the code for the main program is shown, not the module files.

But, if anyone doubts the results, or wants to see, I will post all.


' code (modules not shown) ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

program fact
use reg1001
use reg1008
use conversions
use utility
use time

implicit none
character(len=5000)::s
type(reg1001type)::r11
type(reg1008type)::r81
integer::i,j
real::tt

! First, calculate and print 1000!.

call allocatereg01(r11,numfactorialdigits01(1000))
call allocatereg08(r81,numfactorialdigits08(1000))

call startclock()
call factorial08(r81,1000)
call reg1008toreg1001(r81,r11)
call stopclock()
call elapsedtime(tt)

call reversecopyregtostring01(r11,s)

print*
print'(a)',"1000! = "
print*
call printstring(s)
print*

call deallocatereg01(r11)
call deallocatereg08(r81)

! Now, time and print some big factorials.

print'(a)',"n! t (seconds)"

do i=1,20
j=i*10000

call allocatereg01(r11,numfactorialdigits01(j))
call allocatereg08(r81,numfactorialdigits08(j))

call startclock()
call factorial08(r81,j)
call reg1008toreg1001(r81,r11)
call stopclock()
call elapsedtime(tt)

print'(i6.6,a,f9.3)',j," ",tt

call deallocatereg01(r11)
call deallocatereg08(r81)
enddo

print*

end program

' output ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

C:\Users\root\Desktop\fortran\cat\bin\Release>fact

1000! =

40238726007709377354370243392300398571937486421071463254379991042993851239862902
05920442084869694048004799886101971960586316668729948085589013238296699445909974
24504087073759918823627727188732519779505950995276120874975462497043601418278094
64649629105639388743788648733711918104582578364784997701247663288983595573543251
31853239584630755574091142624174743493475534286465766116677973966688202912073791
43853719588249808126867838374559731746136085379534524221586593201928090878297308
43139284440328123155861103697680135730421616874760967587134831202547858932076716
91324484262361314125087802080002616831510273418279777047846358681701643650241536
91398281264810213092761244896359928705114964975419909342221566832572080821333186
11681155361583654698404670897560290095053761647584772842188967964624494516076535
34081989013854424879849599533191017233555566021394503997362807501378376153071277
61926849034352625200015888535147331611702103968175921510907788019393178114194545
25722386554146106289218796022383897147608850627686296714667469756291123408243920
81601537808898939645182632436716167621791689097799119037540312746222899880051954
44414282012187361745992642956581746628302955570299024324153181617210465832036786
90611726015878352075151628422554026517048330422614397428693306169089796848259012
54583271682264580665267699586526822728070757813918581788896522081643483448259932
66043367660176999612831860788386150279465955131156552036093988180612138558600301
43569452722420634463179746059468257310379008402443243846565724501440282188525247
09351906209290231364932734975655139587205596542287497740114133469627154228458623
77387538230483865688976461927383814900140767310446640259899490222221765904339901
88601856652648506179970235619389701786004081188972991831102117122984590164192106
88843871218556461249607987229085192968193723886426148396573822911231250241866493
53143970137428531926649875337218940694281434118520158014123344828015051399694290
15348307764456909907315243327828826986460278986432113908350621709500259738986355
42771967428222487575867657523442202075736305694988250879689281627538488633969099
59826280956121450994871701244516461260379029309120889086942028510640182154399457
15680594187274899809425474217358240106367740459574178516082923013535808184009699
63725242305608559037006242712434169090041536901059339838357779394109700277534720
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
00000000

n! t (seconds)
010000 1.591
020000 7.410
030000 17.503
040000 32.339
050000 51.824
060000 76.269
070000 105.628
080000 140.541
090000 180.259
100000 224.517
110000 275.092
120000 332.095
130000 393.622
140000 460.437
150000 533.118
160000 610.806
170000 694.423
180000 784.186
190000 876.164
200000 971.309

C:\Users\root\Desktop\fortran\cat\bin\Release>

[danbaron]

Just for something to do, I calculated 300,000 factorial.


' code (modules not shown) ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

program fact
use reg1001
use reg1008
use conversions
use time

implicit none
type(reg1001type)::r1
type(reg1008type)::r8
integer::n
real::et

n=300000
print*

call allocatereg01(r1,numfactorialdigits01(n))
call allocatereg08(r8,numfactorialdigits08(n))

call startclock()
call factorial08(r8,n)
call reg1008toreg1001(r8,r1)
call stopclock()
call elapsedtime(et)

print*
print'(a,f9.3,a)',"calculation time = ",et," seconds"
print*
print'(a,i7,a)',"300,000! has ",r1%maxpower+1," decimal digits."
print*

call deallocatereg01(r1)
call deallocatereg08(r8)

end program

' output ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

C:\Users\root\Desktop\fortran\cat\bin\Release>cat

n! t (seconds)
010000 1.669
020000 7.410
030000 17.425
040000 32.261
050000 51.933
060000 76.596
070000 106.549
080000 141.462
090000 181.538
100000 226.903
110000 277.729
120000 334.373
130000 396.399
140000 463.557
150000 536.378
160000 615.112
170000 699.602
180000 789.443
190000 885.243
200000 986.550
210000 1093.614
220000 1206.590
230000 1325.260
240000 1449.795
250000 1579.822
260000 1715.808
270000 1857.863
280000 2005.190
290000 2158.305
300000 2316.662

calculation time = 2316.802 seconds

300,000! has 1512852 decimal digits.

C:\Users\root\Desktop\fortran\cat\bin\Release>

[danbaron]

I calculated 300,000 factorial using Racket.

It took 1385.916 seconds.

My calculation using Fortran (above), took 2316.802 seconds.

So, Racket was approximately 2317 / 1386 = 1.67 times as fast.

But, when I compared my results using Fortran, to Racket's, for multiplying two 10,000 digit integers, Racket was approximately 62 times as as fast.

http://www.thinbasic.com/community/showthread.php?11560-Faster-Standard-Multiplication&p=85752#post85752

Why the discrepancy in time ratios?

Of course, I don't know what's going on inside Racket, but, my guess is that, it's harder to get a speed improvement using mathematical tricks when multiplying one relatively big integer by one relatively small integer, which is what happens repeatedly in a big factorial calculation, than it is when just multiplying two big integers of the same size.


' code -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

#lang racket

(define value 0)

(define (num-digits n)
(add1 (order-of-magnitude n)))

(define (time-function f n)
(let ((t1 (current-milliseconds)))
(set! value (f n))
(let ((t2 (current-milliseconds)))
(let ((tt (/ (- t2 t1) 1000.0)))
tt))))

(define (fact n)
(define prod 1)
(define (loop m)
(cond
((> m n) prod)
(else
(set! prod (* prod m))
(loop (+ m 1)))))
(loop 1))

' REPL interactions ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Welcome to DrRacket, version 5.2 [3m].
Language: racket.
> (time-function fact 300000)
1385.966
> (num-digits value)
1512852
>